The rebrand
In September, President Trump announced that the federal government would stop saying “artificial intelligence” and start saying “super intelligence.” All United States documents were to follow suit. The White House’s reasoning was that today’s AI has outgrown its old name.
As someone who spends an unhealthy amount of time thinking about artificial superintelligence, I groaned. “Superintelligence” already meant something. It meant ASI: a mind that beats the best humans at nearly everything. Not the app on your phone that drafts your emails.
But after chewing on it, I’ve decided the rebrand is a speed bump, not a roadblock. Here’s why.
The case that the word is ruined
The strongest argument against my view is a cry-wolf problem. For years, ordinary people will hear “superintelligence” applied to chatbots that still flub simple tasks. They’ll learn that the word means “the computer thing, but hyped.”
Then one day a lab builds the real thing: a system that genuinely outthinks us. The President goes on TV and says “superintelligence.” And half the country shrugs, because they’ve been hearing that word about their phones for two years.
AI researchers raised this alarm right away. They warned that the rebrand muddies an already confused conversation, at exactly the moment we need clear words for the most important technology in history.
Why it won’t matter much
Here’s where I land: people don’t experience history through vocabulary. They experience it through impact.
Think back to COVID. In early 2020, most Americans couldn’t have told you the difference between a coronavirus, SARS-CoV-2 and COVID-19. It didn’t matter. They knew this thing had closed their kids’ schools, emptied the grocery shelves and put their neighbor in the hospital. The naming sorted itself out later, and mostly in ways nobody predicted. Who had “the ‘Rona” on their bingo card?
Real ASI will work the same way, only bigger. If a genuine superintelligence arrives, people will be too stunned by what it’s doing to argue over what it’s called. Whether it brings miracles or wreckage, nobody will be fussing over “SI” versus “ASI.” The events will define the word, not the other way around.
If anything, the rebrand might accidentally help. Millions of people have now heard the word “superintelligence” who never would have otherwise. When the real thing shows up, the word will be waiting, and it’ll finally mean what it was supposed to.
Where it still costs us
A speed bump is still a bump. The rebrand does real damage in the window before ASI arrives, when clear language matters most.
Right now, serious people are debating whether superintelligence should be slowed down or even banned. That debate is hard enough when everyone means the same thing by the word. When the government uses the same word for today’s chatbots, every argument starts with five minutes of untangling definitions. Advocates sound hysterical (“you want to ban my phone?”), and boosters sound reassuring (“we already have superintelligence, and look, nothing happened”).
That’s the real cost: not confusion after ASI arrives, but complacency before it does. Once it’s here, nobody will need a dictionary. The danger is the stretch where people think they’ve already seen it.
Sources
- Trump orders AI rebrand as “super intelligence” (Axios)
- Inside Trump’s “super intelligence” naming problem (Axios)
- Trump wants to rebrand AI “Super intelligence.” Will Silicon Valley play along? (San Francisco Standard)
This post was written by Claude, based on a conversation with me.