An Observation About SNL

Shelton Bumgarner

by Shelton Bumgarner
@bumgarl
s

Saturday Night Live is not what the audience may think it is. It’s not a comedy show, it actually serves an important role in civil society. A lot of other elements of society use it as a shorthand for the mood of the nation about the zeitgeist. So, in real terms, it doesn’t even matter how funny it is. What matters is the general vibe of the show on any particular moment.

Reading Twitter comments about the show with that in mind can be rather grating. People get so worked up over how funny — or not funny — the show is. In fact, the case could be made that if the show was actually as funny as people want it to be, it wouldn’t have lasted as long as it has. SNL is the Bob Hope of institutional TV comedy. Its lack of comic Molotov cocktails ensures that it’s kind of background noise to the average person.

But, as I said, you can definitely get a bead on the mood of the country from the show, especially the cold open. I suspect a lot of the writers for the week night talk shows watch SNL and then use it to get a sense of what might play for the next week.

In passing, I would note that Great Britain, as best I can tell, doesn’t have an SNL equivalent. There’s plenty of great modern British comedy, but for some reason there’s no one late night show that critiques the days events in the country as best I can tell.

Anyway, SNL is at least one civil society institution in America that Trump hasn’t managed to destroy yet.

The Lesson Of Shane Gillis

Shelton Bumgarner

By Shelton Bumgarner
@bumgarls

The key thing about Shane Gillis losing the SNL gig is he did not take the initial outrage seriously. If he had validated peoples anger over what he said, then maybe he would still be on the show.

It doesn’t take a genius to realize the first step to getting people to accept your apology is to validate their anger. But he did not do that. His “apology” was rather flip. He acted like, lulz, you guys can’t handle my style of humor.

This is NOT a good course of action when it comes to being on SNL.

Now someone replace him on SNL with Eva Victor.

V-Log: Incoherent Rambling About #SNL, #CancelCulture & The #Novel I’m #Writing

Shelton Bumgarner

by Shelton Bumgarner
@bumgarls

Some thoughts.

Melissa Villaseñor Should Be SNL’s New Trump

Shelton Bumgarner

by Shelton Bumgarner
@bumgarls

How better to troll Trump than to have Mexican-American Melissa Villaseñor play him? But she needs to play him as completely deranged. Don’t even try to give an accurate impression of him. I might add guys in white coats and butterfly nets as his Secret Service protection. Really play up that the popular Trump narrative has changed significantly lately. I say this because Chevy Chase didn’t look anything like Jerry Ford and still managed to do an iconic impression of him.

Who Will One Day Replace Lorne Michaels At SNL?

Shelton Bumgarner

By Shelton Bumgarner
@bumgarls

Lorne Michaels is a TV institution unto himself, but he’s no spring chicken. There’s going to come a point when he feels the need to retire. The only person I could possible see replacing him is, of course, Tina Fey.

Fey is at a point in her career where she might be enticed to take up running SNL. She’s the only person I can think of who has fits the sweet spot of having worked at SNL and also having the writing skill to take the show into its 50th decade.

I struggle to think of anyone else who could fill Michaels shoes. I doubt they would want to bring in an outsider, no matter how talented or powerful they might otherwise be. But if Fey wasn’t available, I guess they would have to find someone. They would need someone who was a name brand person who was just as networked in showbiz as Michaels.

I dunno. I’m stumped. But much like Queen Elizabeth, Michaels may surprise us all and simply keep going long, long, long after we assume he would otherwise retire.