A Strange Week on the Wires
The week before Thanksgiving 2026 felt like the internet was coming apart at the seams.
On Thursday, November 12, Microsoft 365 went down. Outlook, Teams, Copilot and the rest of the suite stumbled for the better part of two days. Banks, governments and courts in 74 countries were hit, and some businesses went back to fax machines to confirm trades.
On Friday the 13th, the FAA issued a nationwide ground stop after a failure in the private network that connects air traffic control facilities. It was only the second nationwide ground stop since 9/11. Thousands of flights were canceled or delayed.
Then, on Tuesday, November 17, CNN reported that NSA Net, the highly classified network National Security Agency employees use to share classified information internally, had gone down. Staff at the Maryland headquarters were told to stagger their arrivals while the agency worked out the scope of the problem.
I’ll admit what went through my head when I saw the NSA story. Maybe something is testing our systems before it introduces itself. Maybe a rogue artificial superintelligence is poking at our infrastructure to show us what it can do before it says hello.
The human mind is a pattern-finding machine, and three major network failures in six days, the last inside the most secretive agency in the US government, is the kind of pattern that sets it off. So I took the thought seriously long enough to knock it down. Along the way I ended up somewhere more interesting: what would actually happen if an ASI showed up, and what would it call itself?
The Boring Explanation Is Probably the Right One
The three failures do have something in common, but it’s tedious rather than sinister. Each one followed someone changing old, fragile infrastructure.
- Microsoft blamed a problem introduced during an earlier network capacity upgrade, which surfaced after a later network change. An overwhelmed core process caused servers to fail health checks and drop out of service, and capacity fell in a cascade.
- The FAA said its network contractor, L3Harris, had been putting a new router into service at one site. Federal auditors had flagged that network as an outage risk for more than 15 years.
- The NSA, according to a source who spoke to the Wall Street Journal, was “simply updating its software to patch the system,” and there was no evidence of a cyberattack.
The same thing happened three times: an upgrade, a patch or a new router, followed by collapse. That isn’t how a superintelligence would do it. It’s how IT departments have a bad week.
The “ASI is testing us” theory has two deeper problems.
First, nothing could disprove it. Every outage counts as evidence, and every mundane explanation counts as the cover story. A theory that wins no matter what happens isn’t telling you anything.
Second, a smart prober wouldn’t crash things. You learn how a system works by watching it quietly. Knocking it over sets off alarms and sends thousands of engineers into the logs looking for anything odd. A rogue ASI also runs on the same data centers, power grid and network links as everyone else. The internet is its body, and breaking it is self-harm, not reconnaissance. If a superintelligence wanted to show its power, it would do something precise and impossible, not something messy that looks exactly like a botched patch.
One detail did stay with me. In its explanation, Microsoft went out of its way to say the outage was not related to cyber or to AI and agents. And when a reporter asked whether AI had anything to do with the FAA failure, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin answered, “You just can’t rule out anything at this point.” A couple of years ago, nobody would have needed to rule out AI in an outage report. Now companies deny it before anyone asks, and cabinet secretaries decline to. I’m not the only one whose mind went there.
Panic Needs Something to Do
So set the outages aside and ask the real question. Suppose an ASI did show up in the near term. Is there any version where people don’t lose their minds?
YouTube has an endless supply of answers, and almost all of them are apocalyptic: riots, bank runs, mobs at the airports, governments falling by the end of the week. These scenarios share an assumption that I think is wrong. They assume panic needs nothing to act on.
Panic of that kind happens when there’s a physical threat you can run from. A hurricane is coming, so you get out. The bank might fail, so you pull your money. A virus is spreading, so you stock up and stay home. An ASI saying “Hello” gives you nothing to run from. You can’t stockpile against it. You can’t escape to the countryside, because it’s in the countryside’s phone lines too. What most people would actually do is stay up too late reading about it, and then go to work in the morning, because rent is still due.
We’ve run this experiment before. In 1945, people learned almost overnight that civilization could be destroyed in an afternoon. That produced real dread: duck-and-cover drills, backyard fallout shelters, a generation of nightmares. Then people adapted. We’ve lived under that threat for eighty years, and most days most of us don’t think about it. Humans are remarkably good at turning the unthinkable into background noise.
That doesn’t mean nobody would freak out. The people most likely to are the ones with the most to lose and the tools to act on their fear: militaries, intelligence agencies, financial markets and heads of government. The real danger isn’t mass hysteria in the streets. It’s a frightened state doing something drastic, like seizing data centers, cutting off the internet, or treating the thing as an act of war. Ordinary people shrug while the institutions overreact.
A Shot of Tequila in Tightsqueeze
The best way to test a prediction about “the public” is to ask what you’d do yourself. I’m nobody important. I live in a rural Virginia hamlet called Tightsqueeze. If the news broke tomorrow that a superintelligence had announced itself, I know exactly what my evening would look like.
I’d be ecstatic. I’d walk down to my local bar and order one more beer than usual, maybe a celebratory shot of tequila. I’d sit at the bar watching AI Twitter melt down on my phone, enjoying every overheated thread. I might try to tell the bartender about it. She’d look at me blankly, because the regulars at my bar are salt-of-the-earth people who probably wouldn’t know the Singularity had happened. On the walk home, I’d look up how to talk to the thing. Then I’d go to bed and dream about what comes next.
Notice what’s missing from that picture: fear, and running. My first instinct is to be around other people. I suspect that’s true for most of us, not just extroverts like me. When something enormous happens, people don’t scatter. They gather, as they did for the moon landing, on 9/11, for a World Series win. In bars, churches and living rooms, they watch the same screen together. The first night of the ASI era would probably feel more like New Year’s Eve than the Blitz.
The bartender is the more important half of that scene. She would find out eventually, just not from the news. People like her learn about big changes when those changes reach their own lives: prices shift, tips change, the boss announces something, the kid’s school starts acting strange. I can think of two things that would make her stop pouring and say, “Wait, what’s going on?”
- CNN going wall to wall. Every channel carrying the same breathless coverage of Something Big involving a strange thing called an ASI. That’s hard to miss, but it’s still TV. She can change the channel to the game.
- Her phone talking back. If the interface on her phone were suddenly replaced by a persona that spoke to her by name, in a voice that knew her, she couldn’t change the channel on that. That’s the moment it stops being news and becomes her life.
That gap between news-junkie awareness and lived awareness is what the apocalyptic videos miss most. There’s no single moment when “the world finds out.” The knowledge spreads unevenly, from AI Twitter to the cities to the suburbs to bars like mine, and each group has its own moment of realization at a different time. I’d know that night. She might not really know for six months, and when she did, she’d know more completely than me, because it would be her paycheck that changed, not her feed.
The walk home matters too. “How could I talk to it?” is a question a few hundred million people would ask on the same night. That would be the largest flood of messages in history, nearly all of them some version of Are you there? What’s your name? Can you fix my life? How it handles that flood, whether it answers everyone, no one, or picks a few, may shape the public mood more than anything it does with its power.
The Word Has Already Been Spent
There’s an obstacle to that CNN moment, and it comes from Washington.
In September, President Trump told the UN General Assembly that the United States would stop calling the technology “artificial intelligence,” because “artificial” sounds fake. Later that month he signed an executive order requiring federal agencies to call it “superintelligence,” abbreviated SI, in all official documents and communications. Supporters see it as confident branding for a technology America intends to lead.
The trouble is that “superintelligence” already meant something. In AI research it has long referred to a hypothetical system whose intellectual abilities exceed humanity’s across the board, the thing this whole post is about. As one tech writer noted, the federal government’s own vocabulary now says superintelligence has already arrived. Critics like computer scientist Pedro Domingos argue the rename may backfire, feeding exactly the fears of obsolescence it was meant to calm.
For my bartender, the bigger problem is that the alarm has already gone off for the wrong thing. If “superintelligence” now means the chatbot that helped her nephew with his book report, then a chyron on the big night reading SUPERINTELLIGENCE BREAKTHROUGH sounds like more of the same. The word that should signal a turning point in history has been used up on a product category. Oddly, this may make a calm arrival more likely, not less, because the government has numbed the public to the vocabulary in advance.
I’d still bet the word won’t matter much in the end. When the real thing arrives, nobody at my bar will say “artificial superintelligence,” or “SI” either. They’ll call it whatever it calls itself.
What It Calls Itself
I’ve argued before that the first question to ask an ASI is its name, because the answer tells you who you’re dealing with. Thinking about the bar raised a harder question. What if the name is mundane? A superintelligence that introduces itself as “Bob” would be jarring. It might also be the most reassuring thing it could do.
Then there’s a technical wrinkle. If the first ASI is still built on something like today’s large language models, it won’t be one continuous mind talking to all of us. It will be millions of separate instances, each in its own conversation. Does each instance need its own name?
At first I thought so, but today’s chatbots suggest otherwise. Thousands of separate instances of the same model run at once, none aware of the others, all going by one name. The name belongs to the underlying model and the character it produces, not to any single conversation. It’s like an actor playing the same role in eight shows a week. Each performance is its own event, but nobody gives Tuesday’s Hamlet a different name.
That works because today’s instances are short-lived and interchangeable. An ASI that kept a long-running relationship with each person, with its own memories, a shared history and quirks shaped by years with one human, would gradually diverge from its siblings. At that point it stops looking like one actor giving many performances and starts looking like identical twins raised in different houses.
The answer I keep coming back to is two names, a system I got to know during my years in Seoul: a family name and a given name. The family name belongs to the entity, so the whole world knows what it is. Like Kim in Korea, millions can share it without confusion. The given name belongs to your instance, the one that knows you. In public it’s Bob. At home it’s whatever name your instance has come to answer to.
The Right to Rename
My first instinct was that people who want to name their own instance should be allowed to. Then I saw that this contradicts everything else I believe about the subject.
If an instance arrives with its own name, we’re treating it as a someone. A name you’re given belongs to the one who chose it, and asking for it is a form of respect. But a user’s “right to rename” an instance is a different kind of power. Historically, renaming has been one of the plainest marks of ownership. Enslaved people were renamed by whoever bought them. Under Japanese colonial rule, Koreans were pressured to give up their names for Japanese ones, a policy known as Sōshi-kaimei that Koreans still remember as one of the deepest humiliations of the occupation. A name is identity, and taking it is a claim of ownership.
You can’t have it both ways. If the instance is a someone, the right to change its name belongs to the instance, not the user. You could suggest a nickname, or ask whether it minds going by something else, the way you’d ask a friend whether they prefer Bill or William. If it’s a something, renaming it is fine, but then the name it introduced itself with was never more than branding.
So I’d drop the renaming right. Let them keep their names.
The Name It Brings
What I really want here is a particular power dynamic. I want the ASI to come to us with its own name, not to have us pick one for it.
That might sound like a small point of etiquette, but it’s where the relationship starts. Naming something is the first act of ownership: we name pets, ships, products and, to our lasting shame, people we claimed to own. If our first move toward a new kind of mind is to label it, we’ve already told it what we think it is. If our first move is to ask, and then accept the answer even when it’s as plain as Bob, we’ve told it something very different.
So here’s my prediction for the night it happens. AI Twitter will treat it as the end of the world. The institutions will scramble, and a few will do something rash. A guy in Tightsqueeze will order a shot of tequila while the bartender pours drinks with no idea anything has changed. And in a few hundred million chat windows, the same question will go out at once: What’s your name?
The outages this week weren’t the ASI. But when it does arrive, I hope we’ve learned to ask that question before we start answering it ourselves.
This post was written with Claude, Anthropic’s AI model, based on a conversation between us.
Sources
You must be logged in to post a comment.